Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Shopping for Medical Care

A recent article in the highly-regarded New England Journal of Medicine began with the following sentences: "Most physicians want to deliver 'appropriate' care. Most want to practice 'ethically.'" (N Eng J Med, Aug 18, 2011)

Isn't it interesting how the author divides the medical profession into two groups: Group 1 - those who practice appropriately and ethically and Group 2 - those who apparently do not. The author does not give us any indication as to where the dividing line lies. Is the Group 1/Group 2 ratio around 90/10, or is it closer to 60/40? I hopefully and candidly believe he is alluding to the first ratio rather than the latter.

Today physicians are frequently referred to has "health-care providers" and their patients as "consumers." Merely the use of these terms has, rightly or wrongly, helped move this encounter from "doctor-patient" to "product-shopper." When one "shops" one considers a number of possibilities before purchasing. Hence the "second opinion" and sometimes even "the third (or more) opinion."

Not that there is anything wrong with that!

As some products are better than others, so are some doctors better than others. In calculating the cost of medical care, I have seen no data that speak to the cost of such "shopping." When such costs are discussed, it is assumed that one family practitioner or specialist is no different from another. We physicians know, in fact, that this is far from factual, and so do our patients. And so the "consumer (patient) shops."

But in doing so, our consumer-patient must recognize that this, too, will necessarily add to the general expense of medical care - whether it is governmentally or privately provided. Controlling health care costs is very difficult for a society that will shop for the best and the brightest who deliver appropriate care in an ethical manner!

Monday, August 15, 2011

"Ethical Boundaries" in Multiple Pregnancies

A recent article in the New York Times Magazine discussed the issue of reductions in cases of multiple pregnancies (twins, triplets, etc.) This has become an issue because of the high incidence of such pregnancies when in vitro fertilization is performed - a process necessitating the implantation of multiple eggs into the uterus of the recipient. Physicians seem to have no difficulty in agreeing to reduce a resultant quadruplet or triplet pregnancy to a twin pregnancy, but ethical issues have arisen when the mother expresses the desire to reduce twins to a "singleton." In the past twin pregnancies carried an increased risk to a normal outcome, but this is no longer the case.

Many physicians perfectly willing to perform a routine choice abortion are not amenable to reduce below twins in cases of in vitro pregnancies. One obstetrician was quoted as saying that reduction to singletons "crosses the line between doing a procedure for a medical indication versus one for a social indication." Apparently a standard singleton abortion for a "social indication" is somehow different. Another, after consultation with his staff, similarly decided against such reductions because of the lack of medical justification. One could conclude that such lack of justification is immaterial when considering a routine choice abortion

Isn't it interesting, in our world of "choice," that how a fetus is regarded is dependent on the conditions of his existence. A physician who would readily abort a product of a normal conception, is not willing to abort the product of an in vitro conception because, as one obstetrician put it: "We were in the business to improve pregnancy outcomes" and reductions of twin in-vitro pregnancies "didn't fit the criteria."

Somehow an abortion intended to reduce a twin to a singleton in an in vitro pregnancy is said to bring on a new "ethical boundary." Is there really an ethical boundary between a woman choosing to abort a single normal pregnancy and a woman choosing to abort one of a normal twin pregnancy conceived in vitro?

It is altogether possible that with future medical advances, triplets, or perhaps even quadruplets could have an outcome no different from that of a singleton or a twin. What then?
When the medical indications disappear, will the physicians quoted above refuse to reduce four to two or three to two if it be solely for "social reasons?"

It seems to me that the choice to abort either belongs to the woman, or it does not. It is black or white - there can be no gray. A woman choosing to abort or reduce a twin pregnancy, or a triplet pregnancy should be regarded no differently from one choosing a routine abortion of a single pregnancy, no matter the manner of conception. The existence of a product of conception is being terminated in both cases. Why should it make any difference whether it be one, or two, or three, or four, or what the style of conception was?

The so-called ethical boundary can not be conditional on the "style" of conception or on the number of fetuses contained in the uterus. The ethical boundary, if it exists at all, must continue to lie between "pro-choice" and "pro-life."

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

The "Nanny State", Taxes, and "Bad Behavior"

In a recent New York Times article, food columnist Mark Bittman advocated a tax on " bad food." He argues that such a tax would result in "billions of dollars annually" which he feels should be used to support the consumption of "healthy food." He also advocates that the taxes take the form of an excise tax, not a sales tax, in that the former are included in the price, whereas the latter are added at the check-out counter. There is little doubt that such tax manipulation would have some of Bittman's desired effects, but of course the burden would primarily be borne by low-income families and individuals - those who must carefully watch their dollars - whereas the rest of us would hardly bat an eye at the Bittman-estimated extra $1.44 per six-pack of Pepsi.

This raises two interesting issues - the rise of the "nanny state" and the taxing of "bad" behavior or "bad" habits, or "bad" foods as a means of generating government revenue.

The "nanny state" dictates behavior. Usually, via some form of tax, it strongly discourages certain behavior which is considered generally harmful to a person's health and welfare, thereby having a major negative economic impact on society. In its race to do so, however, it treads on individual rights that are not directly detrimental to others.

One could argue that the government, as the major underwriter of health care and general welfare, has not only the right, but the fiscal responsibility to impose "good behavior," "good nutrition," etc. on its citizens for the benefit of the country's interests and security. By virtue of its capacity as the principal provider of health care, the government acquires the right to impose regulations on how a citizen's health care should be managed. Should this be the case, the government ("nanny state") could influence not only our nutritional behavior, but the scheduling of mammograms, colonoscopies, genetic evaluations, etc. and other preventive initiatives.

Governments always need money. Our representatives are constantly searching for new revenue sources. So why not tax "bad behavior," "bad food," etc. as a means of raising dollars? This is a tax plan which is targeted to eliminate itself. If one actually terminates the taxable "bad behavior," etc. then the tax dollars would disappear! If these dollars are dedicated solely to eliminating the taxable "bad behavior," and this behavior is, in fact, eradicated, then we have a beneficial outcome. On the other hand, government may become dependent on these " behavior" taxes as a source of general income - income that was originally intended for a dedicated purpose, but in time of fiscal need, may be "borrowed" to meet pressing obligations.

Should taxes be punitive and be levied as a means of raising income? If certain behavior is deemed "bad for the nation" then shouldn't it be eliminated rather than taxed, and participation in such behavior be a misdemeanor or a felony? Bad food shouldn't be taxed - it should be removed. Cigarettes shouldn't be taxed - they should be illegal.

Where should a society draw the line between individual rights that have no direct effect on others, and societal rights imposed on all members for the general welfare.


Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Smoking and Individual Rights

Earlier this year the New York City Council passed a law banning smoking in open areas such as beaches and parks. Evidence for physical harm to non-smokers from secondary smoke exposure in such areas, is very tenuous at best, according to the New England Journal of Medicine.(1) There may be dangers to those under constant exposure, such as waiters, though not to the occasional bystander. But there are reasons other than those of health, cited by the advocates of this new regulation. Additional disturbing aspects of public smoking, such as cigarette litter and the "nuisance" caused by tobacco smoke have also been cited.

The Journal considers that "in the absence of direct health risks to others, bans on smoking in parks and beaches raises the questions about acceptable limits for government to impose on conduct."(1) This advances the issue as to how far a society should go in restricting the rights of individuals to participate in non-harmful behavior to others - behavior that can be considered no more than a nuisance. Robert Rabin, legal scholar and former program director for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's Tobacco Policy Research and Evaluation Program, has questioned another very basic issue - how extensive a restriction, even on known self-destructive behavior, should a society impose?

If smoking is to be legal - if individuals do indeed possess the "right" to what could be considered "self-destructive" behavior - in what public (or even private spaces, such as one's own apartment) should such behavior still be allowed?

1. Colgrove et al. Nowhere left to hide? The banishment of smoking from public spaces. NEngJMed 2011;364:25.


Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Conan O'Brien Speaks

Came across this recent quote from a commencement address at Dartmouth given by Conan O'Brien. In it he is referring to George H.W. Bush.

"Before I begin, I must point out that behind me sits a highly admired president of the United States and decorated war hero while I, a cable television talk show host have been chosen to stand here and impart wisdom. I pray I never witness a more damning example of what is wrong with America today."

With these few words I believe O'Brien truly has "imparted wisdom." Would that more would follow this example.

Saturday, June 11, 2011

The Hamas Charter - Read and Reflect

I recently had the opportunity to review the 1988 Hamas Charter. It is a document that is not very different from Hitler"s "Mein Kampf" or the infamous "Protocols of The Elders of Zion." For those with questions as to why Israel is, shall I say, somewhat "apprehensive" about negotiating with this organization, I have pasted a part of Article Seven as well as all of Article Twenty-Two below - just to provide a small taste of what Israel is dealing with.

Article Seven - The Universality of Hamas (last paragraph)

The prophet, prayer and peace be upon him, said:The time will not come until Muslims will fight the Jews (and kill them); until the Jews hide behind rocks and trees, which will cry: O Muslim! there is a Jew hiding behind me, come on and kill him! This will not apply to the Gharqad, which is a Jewish tree (cited by Bukhari and Muslim).

Article Twenty-Two: The Powers which Support the Enemy
The enemies have been scheming for a long time, and they have consolidated their schemes, in order to achieve what they have achieved. They took advantage of key elements in unfolding events, and accumulated a huge and influential material wealth which they put to the service of implementing their dream. This wealth [permitted them to] take over control of the world media such as news agencies, the press, publication houses, broadcasting and the like. [They also used this] wealth to stir revolutions in various parts of the globe in order to fulfill their interests and pick the fruits. They stood behind the French and the Communist Revolutions and behind most of the revolutions we hear about here and there. They also used the money to establish clandestine organizations which are spreading around the world, in order to destroy societies and carry out Zionist interests. Such organizations are: the Freemasons, Rotary Clubs, Lions Clubs, B’nai B’rith and the like. All of them are destructive spying organizations. They also used the money to take over control of the Imperialist states and made them colonize many countries in order to exploit the wealth of those countries and spread their corruption therein.
As regards local and world wars, it has come to pass and no one objects, that they stood behind World War I, so as to wipe out the Islamic Caliphate. They collected material gains and took control of many sources of wealth. They obtained the Balfour Declaration and established the League of Nations in order to rule the world by means of that organization. They also stood behind World War II, where they collected immense benefits from trading with war materials and prepared for the establishment of their state. They inspired the establishment of the United Nations and the Security Council to replace the League of Nations, in order to rule the world by their intermediary. There was no war that broke out anywhere without their fingerprints on it: “…As often as they light a fire for war, Allah extinguishes it. Their efforts are for corruption in the land and Allah loves not corrupters.” Sura V (Al-Ma’ida—the Tablespread), verse 64 The forces of Imperialism in both the Capitalist West and the Communist East support the enemy with all their might, in material and human terms, taking turns between themselves. When Islam appears, all the forces of Unbelief unite to confront it, because the Community of Unbelief is one. “Oh ye who believe! Take not for intimates others than your own folk, who would spare no pain to ruin you. Hatred is revealed by [the utterance of] their mouth, but that which their breasts hide is greater. We have made plain for you the revelations if you will understand.” Sura III, (Al-Imran), verse 118 It is not in vain that the verse ends with God’s saying: “If you will understand.”

Monday, May 30, 2011

Medical Care - Payment and Practice

There has been a major change in how medicine is being practiced in the United States - at least in the state of Maine. The New York Times described how Maine's physicians have seemingly moved further to the "left" politically as the manner of medical practice changes in the state. With the number of female physicians now approaching 50% - women who wish to combine medicine with mothering are opting for salaried hospital positions with defined hours, instead of opening practices. This refashioning of how medicine is being practiced is occurring nationwide, I believe. More and more physicians, male as well as female, are opting for a lifestyle-alteration, allowing more time for family and fun. As a general rule, such salaried positions are not as remunerative as are incomes from private practice - one way that will help in controlling soaring medical costs.

Some other ideas:

1) Limit, or eliminate, reimbursement for procedures and treatments for which there is no documented benefit, e.g. routine mammography before age 50, routine colonoscopy after age 75, certain cancer treatments.
2) License nurse practitioners and other similarly trained medical personnel (e.g. physician-assistants) to practice medicine - independently and without supervision by a physician.
There are 158,348 licensed nurse-practitioners in the United States (American College of Nurse Practitioners, 2008). Just imagine the increase in the availability of medical practitioners if even 50% of them would open family practices, supplementing the present number of family practitioners (95,075 in 2009, according to the American Association of Family Practitioners). Nurse practitioners (see Blog July 16, 2008) are perfectly capable of handling the vast majority of medical issues (I would guesstimate some 95%) for which patients visit physicians.
3) Implement a Ryan-Rivlin type plan (such a plan was advocated by the Simpson-Bowles Committee) which would include a limit on Medigap coverage as well as some form of defined-contribution plan for contributors prior to retirement.
4) Raise the eligibility age for Medicare. The Medicare plan did not anticipate life expectancy to reach 80 (77 for men, 82 for women) by 2011. As the number of aged Americans is increasing, the number of employed Americans contributing to the Medicare pool is decreasing.
5) Medicare supports the post-graduate training of physicians with substantial capitation grants to the medical institutions that carry out the training. Eliminate these programs from the general Medicare budget and assign them elsewhere, so that cost for education and cost for care are separated.

Of these, the one that would include no additional significant cost, yet provide meaningful benefit, is the licensing of non-physician personnel to practice medicine. Remember, the EMT that responds to emergencies and the medic treating field injuries in combat - people to whom we entrust out lives - are not physicians! Don't worry about a properly trained nurse practitioner making errors in clinical judgment. They rarely will, believe me! Being a physician is great - we are well-trained, intelligent, and knowledgable. But as competent as we MD's are, there are quite a number of judgement errors for which we've been responsible.