We tend to separate man-made from natural products, thereby distinguishing between man and nature as if they were indeed separable. Man and nature are not separable. Man is as much part of nature as is anything else in the known universe, and does not stand apart from it.
Humans are composed of the same atoms and molecules that make up our environment, as are all products made by a human hand. Plastics, aluminum cans, insecticides, atomic waste, dioxin – all the things we have tended to consider as ‘man-made’ and bad for nature and the environment – are, in fact, all ‘natural products’ in that they are made by man, who himself is a part of nature. They, too, are composed of the same atoms and molecules as is everything else in the known universe.
The fact that certain elements produced by nature (whether by the hands of humans or otherwise) are potentially inimical to man’s future, do not make them universally detrimental – they are potentially detrimental only to man and the environment that he proposes as best for himself. It is, in fact, a selfish view - unrelated to the existence of our planet, but only to our own existence.
The planet, in fact, does not exist solely for the human species (except in a spiritual sense). No planet is dedicated merely to the existence of certain species – it never has been and never will be. It’s ultimate purpose, if any, remains utterly mysterious!
Tuesday, December 26, 2006
Sunday, December 17, 2006
The Moral Obligation of Charity
I call your attention to the cover story of the New York Times Magazine of December 17, 2006, entitled What Should a Billionaire Give, and What Should You? by Dr. Peter Singer. Dr. Singer is a contemporary philosopher with a profound-appearing, but really quite simple point of view of the obligations of the haves to the have-nots. I have always admired this ideas; particularly his thought processes.
The confounding factor not included in his discussions is that of human nature - that human beings will not behave in the fashion he feels is obligatory.
He relates his foundation-building anecdote - a helpless child drowning in shallow water - water that any adult could easily enter and save the child. He maintains that no-one would excuse any adult passing this scene who would do nothing to save this child - even if it required walking and wading through muck and slime, ruining a very expensive pair of shoes as well as an extremely costly suit. The price of these items could hardly be considered valuable in comparison with the life of that child.
Dr. Singer goes on from there. Don't miss this. If you wish the article e-mailed to you, please get in touch with me.
The confounding factor not included in his discussions is that of human nature - that human beings will not behave in the fashion he feels is obligatory.
He relates his foundation-building anecdote - a helpless child drowning in shallow water - water that any adult could easily enter and save the child. He maintains that no-one would excuse any adult passing this scene who would do nothing to save this child - even if it required walking and wading through muck and slime, ruining a very expensive pair of shoes as well as an extremely costly suit. The price of these items could hardly be considered valuable in comparison with the life of that child.
Dr. Singer goes on from there. Don't miss this. If you wish the article e-mailed to you, please get in touch with me.
Friday, December 15, 2006
Can Only Roman Catholics Achieve 'Salvation?'
Here are some words I think are important, particularly to individuals with an interest in interfaith relations. I will be paraphrasing an internet article by Fr. John A. Hardon, S.J. entitled On Salvation Outside the Catholic Church.
Fr. Hardon explains that the New Testament is quite clear that Jesus founded the Church to be a society for salvation of all men. The ancient Fathers held the unanimous conviction that salvation cannot be achieved outside the Church!
Gradually, however, it became clear that there existed some "God-fearing" individuals who were deprived of Catholic heritage "without fault on their part." It followed that such people were open to salvation, even though they were not professed Catholics, or even baptized.
Thomas Aquinas, however, restated the teaching about the general necessity of the Church. He did concede that a person could be saved "extra-sacramentally" by a "baptism of desire" and therefore without actual Church membership, but the implicit desire to belong to the Church.
The famous Vatican II Council redefined salvation doctrine as follows:
Fr. Hardon explains that the New Testament is quite clear that Jesus founded the Church to be a society for salvation of all men. The ancient Fathers held the unanimous conviction that salvation cannot be achieved outside the Church!
Gradually, however, it became clear that there existed some "God-fearing" individuals who were deprived of Catholic heritage "without fault on their part." It followed that such people were open to salvation, even though they were not professed Catholics, or even baptized.
Thomas Aquinas, however, restated the teaching about the general necessity of the Church. He did concede that a person could be saved "extra-sacramentally" by a "baptism of desire" and therefore without actual Church membership, but the implicit desire to belong to the Church.
The famous Vatican II Council redefined salvation doctrine as follows:
The Council relies on sacred scripture and Tradition in teaching that this pilgrim Church is necessary for salvation. Christ alone is the mediator of salvation and the way of salvation. This means that it would be impossible for men to be saved if they refused to enter or to remain in the Catholic Church, unless they were unaware that her foundation by God through Jesus Christ made it a necessity.
Hardon goes on to write that salvation, then, is possible without baptism, and people may be saved according to their "adequate cooperation with the internal graces of the Spirit they receive." However, he continues, "whoever is actually saved owes his salvation to the one Catholic Church founded by Christ. It is this Church alone that communicates the merits won for the whole world on the cross."
Is Islamic Terrorism Easing Up?
John Mueller(1), in an Op-Ed article in the New York Times a few months ago, proposed a theory that the non-existence of major terrorist activities and the relative absence of "horrible and disgusting deaths" is a sign of Al Qaeda's (and other Islamic terrorists') waning appeal and effect. He claims that the lack of such significant activities since 9/11 are an indication of this. After all, he writes, a full five years has already passed without further "horrible and disgusting deaths."
This is a meaningless period of time when considering such global events. It is quite naive, I believe, to rate the success or lack thereof, of Islamic terrorism after only five years of "relative quiescence." (1)
It served to remind me of the words attributed to Chou En-Lai, the former Chinese Prime Minister and recognized scholar, when asked by Henry Kissinger about his views of the effects on the world of the French Revolution (1789).
"Too early to tell," he reportedly answered.
(1) Mueller, John: Waiting for Al Qaeda, The New York Times, Op Ed Page, 9/9/06
This is a meaningless period of time when considering such global events. It is quite naive, I believe, to rate the success or lack thereof, of Islamic terrorism after only five years of "relative quiescence." (1)
It served to remind me of the words attributed to Chou En-Lai, the former Chinese Prime Minister and recognized scholar, when asked by Henry Kissinger about his views of the effects on the world of the French Revolution (1789).
"Too early to tell," he reportedly answered.
(1) Mueller, John: Waiting for Al Qaeda, The New York Times, Op Ed Page, 9/9/06
Sunday, December 10, 2006
Germany and the Jews - For your Consideration
Germany is a country with a most unfortunate history. It has a long history of anti-Semitism, but no longer than that of Europe in general. The culmination of German anti-Semitism resulted in human history’s greatest tragedy. Accepting this, however, allow me to raise some issues.
Though born there and forced to leave with my parents in 1939, I have never resorted to accusing all Germans of responsibility for the crimes of the Third Reich – particularly those who were not of adult age at that time and, of course, not those born long after. The Steeg family will never forget the Gestapo officer who was so very instrumental in my father’s release from Dachau, the neighbors who took risks and shopped for them during those horrific times, and the friend who hid a valuable ring for my father, and made certain he received it after arriving in New York.
Holding all Germans guilty for all time for these atrocities brings to mind the axiom that had been drilled into the psyche of Roman Catholics - namely that all Jews for all time bear the guilt of Jesus' crucifixion. Yes, the Jews were clearly complicit in that event, but Vatican II finally put an end to the 'curse be upon you and all your children." We Jews are not a hating people. We should not wait millenia to understand the difference between guilt and innocence!
Post-Holocaust Germans and Jews have had to embark on a very special relationship. A significant number of Germans is honestly coming to grips with the reality of what the Hitler years denoted, not only to the German- Jewish population, but to the German spirit. There is a drive to restore a very meaningful part of German history and German life. It is as if African-American history were erased from our American culture and we Americans were coming to realize what was lost, and how this loss left a deep hole in our cultural history, a hole that we really felt had to be filled.
Many Germans are now dedicated to restoring old Jewish synagogues, community centers and similar physical structures; discovering and re-creating a very important part of their history - a history that had vanished. My wife and I have been actively involved with such an organization - an organization dedicated to the restoration of the Jewish Community Center in Breisach, the village where by mother was born and her forbears had lived since 1755. This association was not started by Jews, has no Jewish members and solicits no Jewish contributions.
Those who do not wish to visit Germany should also consider refraining from visiting Poland, Russia, Slovakia, Czech Republic, Ukraine, Belarus, Austria, Croatia, Hungary, Romania, Russia, Latvia, Lithuania, and even Switzerland and France. Let us not forget their complicity. Germany initiated the Holocaust - Europe helped insure its success. Let us also never forget the inaction of many countries, including our own - their silence and their indifference to the plight of the European Jewry.
The German-Jewish philosopher Emil Fackenheim added to Jewish law what he termed the 614th Commandment: Jews are forbidden to grant posthumous victories to Hitler! It can be argued that not to 'set foot on German soil' disobeys that commandment.
Though born there and forced to leave with my parents in 1939, I have never resorted to accusing all Germans of responsibility for the crimes of the Third Reich – particularly those who were not of adult age at that time and, of course, not those born long after. The Steeg family will never forget the Gestapo officer who was so very instrumental in my father’s release from Dachau, the neighbors who took risks and shopped for them during those horrific times, and the friend who hid a valuable ring for my father, and made certain he received it after arriving in New York.
Holding all Germans guilty for all time for these atrocities brings to mind the axiom that had been drilled into the psyche of Roman Catholics - namely that all Jews for all time bear the guilt of Jesus' crucifixion. Yes, the Jews were clearly complicit in that event, but Vatican II finally put an end to the 'curse be upon you and all your children." We Jews are not a hating people. We should not wait millenia to understand the difference between guilt and innocence!
Post-Holocaust Germans and Jews have had to embark on a very special relationship. A significant number of Germans is honestly coming to grips with the reality of what the Hitler years denoted, not only to the German- Jewish population, but to the German spirit. There is a drive to restore a very meaningful part of German history and German life. It is as if African-American history were erased from our American culture and we Americans were coming to realize what was lost, and how this loss left a deep hole in our cultural history, a hole that we really felt had to be filled.
Many Germans are now dedicated to restoring old Jewish synagogues, community centers and similar physical structures; discovering and re-creating a very important part of their history - a history that had vanished. My wife and I have been actively involved with such an organization - an organization dedicated to the restoration of the Jewish Community Center in Breisach, the village where by mother was born and her forbears had lived since 1755. This association was not started by Jews, has no Jewish members and solicits no Jewish contributions.
Those who do not wish to visit Germany should also consider refraining from visiting Poland, Russia, Slovakia, Czech Republic, Ukraine, Belarus, Austria, Croatia, Hungary, Romania, Russia, Latvia, Lithuania, and even Switzerland and France. Let us not forget their complicity. Germany initiated the Holocaust - Europe helped insure its success. Let us also never forget the inaction of many countries, including our own - their silence and their indifference to the plight of the European Jewry.
The German-Jewish philosopher Emil Fackenheim added to Jewish law what he termed the 614th Commandment: Jews are forbidden to grant posthumous victories to Hitler! It can be argued that not to 'set foot on German soil' disobeys that commandment.
Thursday, December 7, 2006
Avigdor Lieberman's View of the Future of Israel
Avigdor Lieberman, a hawkish member of the Israeli cabinet has long advocated reducing the number of Arabs who are citizens of Israel. His so-called 'racist' proposal is for "dividing Jews and Arabs into two homogeneous states."(1)
He calls for a "land and population exchange that would seek to reduce significantly the number of Arabs who are Israeli citizens. They currently account for more than a million of Israel's 7 million people (14%). Under the plan, several Arab towns in northern Israel would become part of the Palestinian areas in the West Bank. The major Jewish settlement blocs in the West Bank would become part of Israel." " 'We won't be moving people, we will be moving borders,' Mr. Lieberman said."
'In addition, Mr. Lieberman wants to revamp Israel's citizenship laws. All Israelis, Jews and Arabs would have to pledge loyalty to the state and recognize Israel as a Jewish state. Those who refuse could be permanent residents, but would no longer be citizens.'(1)
This plan has no apparent support from Israelis or from Arabs and has been termed 'racist' by Israeli Arab leaders.
Lets consider this for a minute. Israel is an unusual democracy - a democracy which contains the term 'Jewish' in its credo. The implication here is that Israel must always maintain a significant Jewish majority. What is a significant Jewish majority. According to today's New York Times, Jews make up 86% of the population. What if it falls to 75%? Could it possibly fall to 50%, or maybe 40%? Then what happens? Should a decreasing Jewish majority eventuate, what should be done?
I know of no solution that seems as fair as that of Mr. Lieberman. He indicates, in the article, that separation of warring factions in a country has worked in the past (e.g. Yugoslavia, India-Pakistan, Pakistan-Bangladesh, Czech Republic-Slovakia, Romania-Moldova, Indonesia- East Timor) Ethnic confrontations continue in places like Sudan, Sri Lanka and Somalia. A solution of separation may be in their futures as well.
If we correctly assume that a Jewish minority in Israel is unacceptable, then some such solution must be seriously considered.
What about it?
(1) Myre, Greg Israeli Official Discusses Iran and his Controversial Agenda: NY Times 12/7/06, page A10.
He calls for a "land and population exchange that would seek to reduce significantly the number of Arabs who are Israeli citizens. They currently account for more than a million of Israel's 7 million people (14%). Under the plan, several Arab towns in northern Israel would become part of the Palestinian areas in the West Bank. The major Jewish settlement blocs in the West Bank would become part of Israel." " 'We won't be moving people, we will be moving borders,' Mr. Lieberman said."
'In addition, Mr. Lieberman wants to revamp Israel's citizenship laws. All Israelis, Jews and Arabs would have to pledge loyalty to the state and recognize Israel as a Jewish state. Those who refuse could be permanent residents, but would no longer be citizens.'(1)
This plan has no apparent support from Israelis or from Arabs and has been termed 'racist' by Israeli Arab leaders.
Lets consider this for a minute. Israel is an unusual democracy - a democracy which contains the term 'Jewish' in its credo. The implication here is that Israel must always maintain a significant Jewish majority. What is a significant Jewish majority. According to today's New York Times, Jews make up 86% of the population. What if it falls to 75%? Could it possibly fall to 50%, or maybe 40%? Then what happens? Should a decreasing Jewish majority eventuate, what should be done?
I know of no solution that seems as fair as that of Mr. Lieberman. He indicates, in the article, that separation of warring factions in a country has worked in the past (e.g. Yugoslavia, India-Pakistan, Pakistan-Bangladesh, Czech Republic-Slovakia, Romania-Moldova, Indonesia- East Timor) Ethnic confrontations continue in places like Sudan, Sri Lanka and Somalia. A solution of separation may be in their futures as well.
If we correctly assume that a Jewish minority in Israel is unacceptable, then some such solution must be seriously considered.
What about it?
(1) Myre, Greg Israeli Official Discusses Iran and his Controversial Agenda: NY Times 12/7/06, page A10.
Tuesday, December 5, 2006
The Advocacy of Disease
The New York Times Science Section (Dec 5, 2006) contains an article entitled Wanting Babies Like Themselves, Some Parents Choose Genetic Defects.
You may not believe this, but the article discusses parents with handicaps (dwarfed individuals and deaf ones) who wish their children to be born with the same disorders "to preserve culture and identity." To make matters even more astonishing, it describes these parents in a sympathetic light. Yet even more astounding is the fact that there are physicians who would consent to genetic engineering in order to provide these parents with deformed children.
I mean, come on, political correctness is getting to be a joke!! Do such parents truly believe that by 'maiming' their unborn they could possibly have the wishes of the child in mind? Do they really think a child would choose to be deaf, rather than hearing? I mean, come on, there are parental rights, but isn't this truly a form of abuse? Would they insist on a physician surgically imposing deafness on a hearing infant after it had been born? Why not? Isn't that more or less the same thing?
And the fact that physicians exist who would agree to genetic alteration to promote a disorder to satify the wishes of such deranged people, is the greatest of the tragedy of it all!
You may not believe this, but the article discusses parents with handicaps (dwarfed individuals and deaf ones) who wish their children to be born with the same disorders "to preserve culture and identity." To make matters even more astonishing, it describes these parents in a sympathetic light. Yet even more astounding is the fact that there are physicians who would consent to genetic engineering in order to provide these parents with deformed children.
I mean, come on, political correctness is getting to be a joke!! Do such parents truly believe that by 'maiming' their unborn they could possibly have the wishes of the child in mind? Do they really think a child would choose to be deaf, rather than hearing? I mean, come on, there are parental rights, but isn't this truly a form of abuse? Would they insist on a physician surgically imposing deafness on a hearing infant after it had been born? Why not? Isn't that more or less the same thing?
And the fact that physicians exist who would agree to genetic alteration to promote a disorder to satify the wishes of such deranged people, is the greatest of the tragedy of it all!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)