Sunday, November 27, 2011

"Artfully Sheltering" Your Money

The lead article on page one of the New York Times today (Nov 27, 2011) concerned the "Artfully Sheltered" wealth of Ronald S. Lauder, heir to the Estée Lauder fortune.  The piece goes on to describe Mr. Lauder's "shrewd use of the United States tax code" to shelter his substantial income.  Many examples are listed.  Lauder is criticized for generating charitable deductions (which support many worthy enterprises) as just one "facet of a sophisticated tax strategy used to preserve a fortune...."  He is said to have been involved in a "tax-sheltering stock deal so audacious that Congress later enacted a law forbidding the tactic."

What is the message here - the lead story in the Sunday New York Times?  Are readers to find Lauder's financial "shenanigans" intolerable, and regard him as nothing more than an execrable member of the "1%."  What has Lauder done?  Has he broken a law?  Has he been too meager with his benevolent financial assistance?  Has he bilked naive investors of money?  Has he run a Ponzi scheme?  Has he been nefarious in not publicly calling for the elimination of tax loopholes? 

Ronald Lauder is no crook.  The article cites no illegalities.  His actions are the actions just about every one of us would take.  We are all "guilty" of using  loopholes as methods to limit our taxes.  Most of us would opt for ourselves before we opt for the "greater good."  Most all of us are dedicated to preserving our fortunes for ourselves and for our heirs.  When our tax preparers advise us of legal ways to preserve income, we jump at them - gleefully embracing legal tax havens!

Rather than making Lauder seem like the "bad guy," the Times should have emphasized who the real bad guys are - Congress.  Lauder and his wealthy cohorts did not write the tax codes.  Lauder is doing what every red-blooded American seems to do - finding legal ways to preserve his wealth.  If we want Lauder, etc. to start paying more taxes, it is up to us to close those tax gaps!  If we don't want wealth to be perpetuated for fear of advancing a plutocracy, perhaps we should eliminate the ease with which this is accomplished.  "Occupy Wall Street" should be "Occupy Washington" (with the appropriate acronym "Ow!")

It is wrong to crucify the wealthy for legally-acquired wealth.  It is wrong to crucify the wealthy for  attempts to legally retain and pass on their wealth.  We would all do the same.  It is we, the people - the "99%" and the "1%" - who bear the responsibility to change a system we feel is not equitable - and to do so thoughtfully and legally

Thursday, November 17, 2011

Israel - A State or a "Jewish" State


"His Majesty's Government views with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people  and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country."

These are the words of the 1917 Balfour Declaration.  "Jewish Homeland in Palestine" was also the term used in the original 1897 Zionist Declaration at Basel.

Does "Jewish Homeland in Palestine" imply a "Jewish State?"  Should Israel be regarded as "The State of Israel" or "The Jewish State of Israel?"  A series of articles in the current issue of Foreign Affairs addresses this issue.

With a significant growth in Israeli Jewish ethnocentrism,  questions have been raised as to how non-Jewish Israelis could not be considered as "second class" in a Jewish State.   Is it not difficult for  such a citizen to relate to the strikingly Jewish symbols of the Israeli state - its flag, its seal, its national anthem?  Is it possible for a Jewish state to be governed by a non-Jewish prime minister?  Is it possible for a future Jewish state to have, a citizenry which is only 50% ethnically Jewish?  (It is now less than 80% Jewish.)  It was interesting to read that neither Jordan nor Egypt, though recognizing Israel, acknowledges Israel as a Jewish state.

To us Jews Israel is unique and our relationship to Israel is unique.  Many Jews (if not most) draw a very thin line, or perhaps no line at all, between Israel and Judaism.  We are ethnically and historically and religiously forever joined at the hip!  I can think of no other extant 5000-year-old people-land connection.  As Jews, in our hearts, Israel is and always will be The Jewish State!

But that's us.  And we are not the world!

When I was a boy Christmas was celebrated in my public elementary school every year.  I learned all the carols which were to be sung at "assemblies."  Jewish holidays were unrecognized and, for the most part, unfamiliar to our teachers.  Weekly "assemblies" started with a hymn (Abide With Me) or The Lord's Prayer (which, of course, I still can sing and recite.)  I can't say that it bothered me very much at the time, but it certainly made me regard my standing as very different from that of the overwhelming majority of my fellow students.  They were part of the "real America," whereas I was a member of a sort of "subset of America." Things are clearly quite different today.  P.S. 22 of 1945 is not P.S. 22 of 2011!  Though "Christian" is a very important concept in the history of the United States, the exclusive teaching of Christian customs and liturgy is no longer permitted.


Right or wrong, the terms  "Jewish State," "Muslim State," "Christian Republic," or "Buddhist Republic" - even "Gallic State" or "Anglo-Saxon State" - imply an ethnic or religious affiliation contained within that "state" associating it with a particular religion or ethnic identity which may be incompatible with the views of a significant minority of its citizenry.

Thinking objectively (not easy) it may prove more constructive if ethnic and/or religious references were omitted from the names and identities of states, since such recognition would tend to promote exclusivity on the one hand, and exclusion on the other.  History is replete with nation-states, but the concept of a true nation-state is very questionable today.  I strongly believe in Israel as the home of the Jewish people and as a state that should be culturally and historically Jewish.  But, perhaps illogically, to include the subtitle "The Jewish State" is somewhat difficult to accept.




Saturday, November 5, 2011

Abortion - The Ineffective Pro-Choice Arguments

The abortion wars continue.  A recent article in the respected New England Journal of Medicine addresses the issue of "The Supply Side Economics of Abortion."  It points out that attempts to limit pregnancy terminations are now being accomplished by making it more difficult for such facilities to set up shop (the supply side.)  Up to now, difficulties in obtaining abortions were effected primarily on the "demand side," - waiting periods, parental consent, counseling, etc.  Regulations, citing safety issues, are now mandating space requirements for abortion clinics that make it far more expensive to construct them.  Additionally, a number of states (Missouri, Virginia, Arizona) are requiring facilities performing abortions to update to "hospital status," or that the carrying out of abortions be restricted to physicians only.  (In many facilities they are performed by fully qualified nurse practitioners or physician-assistants.)  These are the "supply side" issues discussed.

Yes, attempts to restrict or eliminate abortion continue - and always will.  Yes abortion has always been with us, and will most likely continue to be with us in the future.  But be sure to understand the motivation of "pro-lifers."  Realize that no argument exists that will budge them from their point of view - their belief in what constitutes a human life.  Arguments - that abortion, legal or not, will always be part of our civilization, or that an increase in "back room" abortions will result in an increase in significant morbidity and mortality, or that giving birth to "unwanted" children will only result in a greater number of ill-cared for and abandoned children - are destined to fall on deaf ears.  Justifying the procedure as being a woman's prerogative will not work.  As a nine-month old fetus is hardly considered merely a part of the mother's body, so, too, the newly created product of conception.

The conviction that the preservation of innocent life is a moral imperative will eternally close the mind of the believer to such arguments.  No true believer will ever consent to the "murder" of a human being in order to accomplish, or in order to prevent, any foreseeable incident.  One does not "kill" a human being that was created as a result of rape or incest. One does not "kill" a human being because it may be economically advantageous, etc.  It is important to always remember that to a "pro-lifer" a product of conception exists as a human being (has the same DNA) from the moment of fertilization to birth, infancy and beyond.  This moral imperative is permanently moored in the "pro-lifer."

Those of us who are pro-choice must invariably stay aware of the powerlessness of our arguments.




Monday, October 31, 2011

Occupy Wall Street v. Indian Fasting

I would like to highlight some of Bill Keller's op-ed piece, Beyond Occupy, which appeared in the New York times on October 31.

Mr. Keller, writing from New Delhi, attempted to interview the" contemporary Indian 'Ghandi'", Anna Hazare.  Mr. Hazare, as you may know, had been on a recent hunger strike in order to exert pressure on the Indian government to institute reforms.  These fasts have apparently resulted in a number of successful results.  Keller points out that Hazare's Indian campaign is hardly anti-capitalism.  Hazare's aim, says Keller, "is to stop a political class from usurping the fruits of capitalism."  A Hazare spokesman (Hazare himself has taken a "vow of silence") is quoted as indicating "we're not anti-capitalism.  We're pro-integrity."  Hazare's spokesman called the Occupy Wall Street movement "engaging," but lacking in a destination!  "We had a destination," he said.

Keller summarizes his column a follows:  "I'm prepared to celebrate when the Occupiers - like the lone hunger artist of India - accomplish something more than organizing their own campsite cleanup, demonstrating their tolerance for tear gas, and distracting the conversation a little from the Tea Party.  So far the main achievement of Occupy Wall Street is showing up."

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Wealth Distribution - How "Poor" is "Poor?"

Occupy Wall Street!  Re-distribute wealth!  OK, it's clear that inequality in wealth exists in America (as it does in all "developed" countries.)  If we genuinely want to create more equality in wealth-distribution in the United States, how do we do this?  Not by taxation.  Lets assume Billionaire Bill, with accumulated wealth of $30 billion earns (with outstanding advice and insight) 20% on his investments.  That calculates to $6 billion.  Even if we tax him at 80%, it still leaves Bill with $1.2 billion to add to his $30 billion.  One can't create equality by taxation initiatives.  We can try to narrow the gap by putting a ceiling on income and wealth.  Laws can be instituted to limit wages to some multiple of a calculated "poverty wage" in the country.  Assuming a base poverty-level income of $20,000, maximum income could be restricted to a multiple of 20 x $20,000, or $400,000, a difference of $160,000.  Needless to say this is a generalized illustration; there would be modifying factors.

But consider the implications.  If this formula were in place, one would anticipate that the lowest income level would rise by re-distribution.  But as it rises, of course, the upper level would continue to rise by a factor of 20.  A new base of $40,000 would result in a ceiling of $800,000, or inequality that has now reached $760,000.  As the level rises, so does the difference between the extremes of income.  Now, since money begets money, the richer will get richer.  Yes, the "poor"will also get richer, but the difference in the extremes will continue.

Are today's "underprivileged" "99%" so much worse off than the "privileged" "1%?"

Let's examine the "poor households" in the United States:  43% own a home, 73% own a car or truck, 31% own two or more cars, 80% have air-conditioning, 37% have a dishwasher, 97% have a color TV, 55% have two or more color TVs, 63% have cable or satellite TV,  etc. (1) Not too shoddy.  The poor American (as defined by the government) reports that his family is not hungry and has the funds to meet essential needs and access to quality medical care.  While life is not opulent, dire poverty, as we often imagine it, exists only rarely in the United States.

Another interesting statistic:  Housing space per capita (in square feet): US - 721,  US poor - 439, High income countries (UK, France, Germany, Japan) - 377, Low income countries (Egypt, Philippines, Morocco) - 95, Very low income countries (India, China, Nigeria) - 66.  By the way, this comparison of US poor is to "average," not "poor," populations of the listed countries. (2)

Yes, poverty exists in America, but although some 12% of Americans are classified as "poor" very few actually lack essential resources. Yes, disparity exists....and, I believe, always will.  As long as there is equality of opportunity, there will be inequality of success,  as defined by income or by any other criteria.   Should we somehow place a financial limit on wealth disparity?  Will such a system be better for America?  Could it be worse?  Are the "poor"really "poverty-stricken" in the true sense of this condition?  Inequality is not the same as inequity.

Sources:  1. US Census Bureau, American Housing Survey for the US 2003,2005.  US Dept of Energy 2001. 
               2. UN Center for Human Settlements and World Bank, 1993.  US Dept of Energy, 2007.
                    www.heritage.org/research/reports/2007/2008/                      

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Opting Out v. Opting In

How do you feel about "opting out" as opposed to "opting in?"  This recently became a subject of interest in the Republican presidential debates.  Gov. Rick Perry defended his signing of a bill passed by the Texas legislature requiring all girls of a certain age to be vaccinated against HPV (human papilloma virus).  HPV can be precursor to cancer of the cervix.  His argument, when challenged by those who maintained that this was government interfering with a decision that should be left to families, was that the legislation included an "opt out" clause, allowing unwilling families to do just that - opt out.

What about this "opting out" choice?  It seems to me that for any organization (government, business, health facility, etc.) the "opt out" option clearly favors the organization rather than the individual.   "Opting in" is  an intentional choice.  "Opting out" is a default choice.  Very different!  It is much easier to not respond than to respond.  Businesses are well aware of that fact - especially book clubs and magazine subscription services.  "We will send you this book if we don't hear from you by...." is quite a contrast from "Once we receive your order, we will send you this book." There are obvious reasons why the default option rather than the intentional choice option is offered.

"Opt-out" (default) choices have a ring of speciousness about them.   When a choice is in the offing, doesn't an "opt-in" (intentional) choice seem far more equitable?

Friday, October 14, 2011

History Does Not Repeat Itself

History does not repeat itself. We can learn from historical events, but we cannot use them to predict future occurrences. And that is because yesterday is never the same as today and today is never the same as tomorrow. Things change. Facts affecting events change. Players participating in events change. Situations affecting events are ever changing. Change fuels the world and does not permit the retrospective analysis of history to be the sole decider in decision making. Such an analysis can serve only as a background for decisions affecting today.

Has history helped us avoid conflict? Is the world a better place because of the lessons of history? I think we would all agree that the answers to both questions are a resounding "no!"

History seems to cycle rather consistently. That is the one, if only, true historical fact. Wars, man-made disasters, non man-made disasters, financial crises, crises of thoughts and ideas - ever constant, but never the same.

Programs instituted to stem the depression of the '30s cannot be the answer to our present financial debacle. Early 20th century is not early 21st century: trading in the stock market is different, corporate management is different, the value of currency is different, the population is different, the people in control are different. The world is different.

Ahmadinejdad's antisemitism is not Hitler's antisemitism: the situation is different, the world is different, weapons are different, spread of information is different, the organization of countries is different, the population is different, the people in control are different.

Slogans echoing a reference to a past occurrence, such a "Don't forget Munich!" (vis-a-vis the Iran issue) should serve only to remind us of the event, but never to intend for us to respond to today's issue as we feel we should have to yesterday's. Remember history. Learn from history. But do not become a prisoner of history! The world of today "resembles" but does not "mirror" the world of the past.